Romance of the Underworld

Romance of the Underworld
Film poster
Directed byIrving Cummings
Written byDouglas Z. Doty (screenplay)
Garrett Graham (intertitles)
Story byDouglas Z. Doty
Sidney Lanfield
Based onA Romance of the Underworld
by Paul Armstrong
Produced byWilliam Fox
StarringMary Astor
CinematographyConrad Wells
Edited byFrank Hull
Distributed byFox Film Corporation
Release date
  • November 11, 1928 (1928-11-11)
Running time
68 minutes; 7 reels (6,162 feet)
CountryUnited States
LanguagesSound (Synchronized)
(English Intertitles)

Romance of the Underworld is a 1928 American synchronized sound drama film produced and distributed by Fox Film Corporation. While the film has no audible dialog, it was released with a synchronized musical score with sound effects using the sound-on-film movietone process. Directed by Irving Cummings and starring Mary Astor, it was based upon the 1911 stage play A Romance of the Underworld by Paul Armstrong. A previous version of the story was filmed as A Romance of the Underworld in 1918 by director James Kirkwood with Catherine Calvert in Astor's part.

Plot

Judith Andrews (Mary Astor), once a sweet country girl, comes to the city only to fall on hard times. Unable to find respectable work, she reluctantly accepts employment as a “hostess” in a seedy night club — a thinly disguised dance-hall dive. Though she hides her distaste, she dreams of escaping the life.

One night, during a police raid, Detective Edwin Burke (Robert Elliott) singles her out. Seeing she is different from the others, he questions her briefly, advises her to “keep on running,” and lets her go. Meeting her again outside as she cries, he hands her a handkerchief — and inside it she finds a ten-dollar bill, a small act of kindness that stays with her.

Determined to change, Judith leaves the night club for work in a laundry, then as a waitress, and finally studies typing and stenography. She earns a respectable office position. In time she attracts the attention of Stephen Ransome (John Boles), the young vice president of the firm. Unaware of her past, Stephen falls in love with her. Judith agrees to marry him, on the condition he never ask about her former life.

Their wedding is to be held in a judge’s chambers. By coincidence, that same day Stephen’s friend Derby Dan Manning (Ben Bard) is brought before the judge and sentenced to two years in prison. Dan is an old underworld acquaintance of Judith’s.

Upon his release, Dan tracks Judith to her home, posing as a radio repairman. He confronts her, revealing he knows her past, and steals a bracelet and ring. He offers to return them only if she brings him $5,000 in cash that night.

Rather than submit, Judith turns to Detective Burke (Robert Elliott), whom she hasn’t seen since the raid. Burke’s manner remains calm, almost bored, but his mind is working quickly. He knows that Champagne Joe (Oscar Apfel), a criminal associate, has a score to settle with Dan, who once stole Joe’s sweetheart Flossie (Helen Lynch).

Burke discreetly sets Joe against Dan, letting one crook deal with another. Off-screen, Joe eliminates Dan — only a single gunshot is heard, with no melodramatic death scene shown. Burke thus spares Judith from blackmail without implicating her.

Stephen Ransome (John Boles) learns of Judith’s past. At first stunned, he quickly realizes his love outweighs the revelations and forgives her. The danger removed, Judith’s happiness is secure. Burke returns quietly to his ordinary home life, a family man once more.

Cast

Scene from the movie

Uncredited

Music

The film featured a theme song titled "Judy", which was composed by Irving Kahal, Sammy Fain, and Pierre Norman.

Censorship considerations

The Motion Picture Producers and Distributors of America, formed by the film industry in 1922, regulated the content of films through a list of subjects that were to be avoided. While Mary Astor portrayed a prostitute in Romance of the Underworld, this was acceptable as prostitution was not explicitly barred so long as it was not forced (i.e., white slavery) and aspects of her work were not shown in the film.[1] Here the work of Astor's character is ambiguously described as being a "hostess."

Preservation

Romance of the Underworld is extant at the Museum of Modern Art[2][3] and in a European archive.[4]

See also

References

  1. ^ Campbell, Russell (1997). "Prostitution and Film Censorship in the USA". Screening the Past (2): C/6. Retrieved July 5, 2020.
  2. ^ Progressive Silent Film List: Romance of the Underworld at silentera.com
  3. ^ The American Film Institute Catalog Feature Films: 1921-30 by The American Film Institute, c. 1971
  4. ^ The Library of Congress/FIAF American Silent Feature Film Survival Catalog:Romance of the Underworld