Enforced disappearances during The Franco Regime
Enforced disappearances during The Franco Regime | |
---|---|
![]() Mass grave in Estépar, Burgos province, containing 26 Republican victims. Excavation took place in July and August 2014. | |
Location | Francoist Spain |
Date | 1936-1976 |
Victims | At least 140,000 |
According to the Platform of Victims of Forced Disappearances under Franco, more than 140,000 people disappeared during the Franco regime, including victims of the Spanish Civil War and the subsequent Franco dictatorship.[1] The most recent academic studies estimated the number of victims of Francoist repression during the war at 130,199 and the number of victims of Republican repression at 49,272.[2]
According to Miguel Ángel Rodríguez Arias, a researcher in criminal law at the University of Castilla-La Mancha, Spain is the only democracy that has not conducted any investigation into state terrorism after the end of the dictatorship.[3]
The UN has repeatedly called on Spain to investigate both the crimes of Franco's regime and the disappeared during the dictatorship.[4][5][6] The Permanent Commission of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe unanimously approved a condemnation of the Franco regime in which it urged the Spanish government, among other tasks, to create a commission of inquiry into the crimes of the dictatorship.[7]
Introduction
Several decades have passed since the Kingdom of Spain ratified the European Convention on Human Rights in 1979, and the whereabouts of tens of thousands of victims of the Spanish Civil War and the subsequent Franco dictatorship remain unknown.[8]
Articles 2 and 13 of this Convention[9] establish the obligation to undertake an "effective and independent official investigation" into all reported cases of disappearance. At least 143,353 people have disappeared,[10] not including missing children or those missing in action. In Andalusia alone, with 54,000 missing people in mass graves, there are more missing people than adding together the crimes of forced disappearance of people committed in Chile, Argentina, Peru and Guatemala.[11] Before the judicial investigation undertaken by Baltasar Garzón from the National Court, and in the absence of prior investigation by the State, it was erroneously estimated that the number of missing people during the Franco regime did not exceed 30,000 victims,[12] figures that, from revisionist and denialist theses, were trying to diminish or even deny.[13]
Historical context
The military rebellion carried out from July 17 to 18, 1936, against the government of the Second Republic, began what became known as the Spanish Civil War, which officially ended on April 1, 1939. During this civil war, and the subsequent dictatorship established by its victors, Franco and his generals carried out a systematic persecution of the defenders of the Spanish Republic. This included, among other forms of repression that could be classified as crimes against humanity, various forms of disappearance of persons.[14]
After the restoration of democracy in Spain and the reinstatement of the monarchy in its parliamentary form, the majority of those disappeared during the dictatorship continue to be so.[15]
Figures of missing persons during the regime
According to the newspaper La Nueva España, the data provided in the order of the Audiencia Nacional of October 16, 2008,[16] referring to missing persons in mass graves are the following:
Autonomous community | Total missing | Province | Missing |
---|---|---|---|
Andalucía | 32,289 | Almería | 373 |
Cádiz | 1,665 | ||
Córdoba | 7,091 | ||
Granada | 5,048 | ||
Huelva | 3,805 | ||
Jaén | 3,253 | ||
Málaga | 7,797 | ||
Sevilla | 3,257 | ||
Aragón | 10,178 | Huesca | 2,061 |
Teruel | 1,338 | ||
Zaragoza | 6,779 | ||
Asturias | 1,246 | Gijón | 1,246 |
Islas Baleares | 1,777 | Mallorca | 1,486 |
Menorca | 106 | ||
Ibiza y Formentera | 185 | ||
Canarias | 262 | Gran Canaria | 200 |
Tenerife | 62 | ||
Cantabria | 850 | N/A | N/A |
Castilla-La Mancha | 7,067 | Albacete | 1,026 |
Ciudad Real | 1,694 | ||
Cuenca | 377 | ||
Toledo | 3,970 | ||
Castilla y León | 12,979 | Ávila | 650 |
Burgos | 4,800 | ||
León | 1,250 | ||
Palencia | 1,180 | ||
Salamanca | 650 | ||
Segovia | 370 | ||
Soria | 287 | ||
Valladolid | 2,555 | ||
Zamora | 1,237 | ||
Cataluña | 2,400 | N/A | N/A |
C. Valenciana | 4,345 | Alicante | 742 |
Castellón | 1,303 | ||
Valencia | 2,300 | ||
Extremadura | 10,266 | N/A | N/A |
Galicia | 4,396 | N/A | N/A |
La Rioja | 2,007 | N/A | N/A |
Madrid | 2,995 | N/A | N/A |
Murcia | 855 | N/A | N/A |
Navarra | 3,431 | N/A | N/A |
País Vasco | 9,459 | Álava | 100 |
Guipúzcoa | 340 | ||
Vizcaya | 369 | ||
Datos del Gobierno Vasco | 8,650 | ||
Ceuta, Melilla y Norte de África | 464 | N/A | N/A |
Otros territorios | 7,000 | N/A | N/A |
Total: 114,266. These figures that would be increased to 143,353 during the course of the proceedings.
References
- ^ "Garzón recibe más de 140.000 nombres de desaparecidos en la Guerra Civil y la dictadura | elmundo.es". www.elmundo.es. Retrieved 2025-08-14.
- ^ Violencia roja y azul : España, 1936-1950. ISBN 9788498921168.
- ^ "Al menos 88.000 víctimas del franquismo continúan sepultadas en fosas comunes". Público. August 30, 2012. Archived from the original on September 1, 2012.
- ^ EFE, RTVE es / (2013-11-06). "El Gobierno se queja por la "excesiva atención" de la ONU a los desaparecidos del franquismo". RTVE.es (in Spanish). Retrieved 2025-08-14.
- ^ "La ONU exige a España que elabore un plan nacional de búsqueda de desaparecidos durante el franquismo". Público.
- ^ "La ONU afea a España su nula voluntad de investigar los crímenes de Franco". ElHuffPost (in Spanish). 2014-02-03. Retrieved 2025-08-14.
- ^ Cué, Carlos E. (2006-03-18). "El Consejo de Europa condena el franquismo e insta a España a honrar a sus víctimas". El País (in Spanish). ISSN 1134-6582. Retrieved 2025-08-14.
- ^ "Memoria Histórica". www.memoriahistorica.org.es (in European Spanish). Archived from the original on 2014-10-20. Retrieved 2025-08-14.
- ^ The new "memory law" and the violation of articles 2 and 13 of the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights in the case of those who disappeared during the Franco regime, Miguel Ángel Rodríguez Arias, Judges for Democracy, ISSN 1133-0627, No. 63, 2008, pp. 68-85
- ^ AGENCIA EFE (2008-09-23). Garzón recibe 143.353 nombres de desaparecidos del franquismo . Retrieved 2025-08-14 – via YouTube.
- ^ Justice and the "Disappeared" of the Chilean and Argentine Dictatorships, Pedro Crespo Barquero, Impunity and the Right to Memory: From Pinochet to Timor / coord. by Iva Delgado, 2000, ISBN 84-95363-07-0, pp. 58-64
- ^ Spain: 30,000 missing persons await truth and justice, buried in clandestine graves (PDF) (Report). Amnesty International. 2003. p. 37. ISSN 1023-8328.
- ^ Missing: Stolen Stock (PDF) (Report). Amnesty International. 2008. p. 4. ISSN 1023-8328.
- ^ Torres, Rafael (2002). Desaparecidos de la guerra de España (1936-?). ISBN 84-9734-079-5.
- ^ The Transition and the Republican Disappearances, Vicenç Navarro, The Memory of the Forgotten: A Debate on the Silence of Franco's Repression / coord. by Emilio Silva, Pancho Salvador, Asunción Esteban, Javier Castán, 2004, ISBN 84-8183-132-8, pp. 115-132
- ^ "Report". La Nueva España. 16 October 2008. Archived from the original on 19 February 2023. Retrieved 27 January 2015.